Butash Law Group
Open 24/7

The auto insurance company’s attorney says my injury was pre existing how do I prove it was not?

The auto insurance company's attorney says my injury was pre existing how do I prove it was not?


The auto insurance company’s attorney says my injury was pre existing how do I prove it was not?


For contrary to popular belief, it is possible for you to recover for injuries that aggravate a preexisting condition. Now obviously the insurance company is going to say that the injuries that you are currently suffering from existed from a prior injury or have existed at least prior to this car accident. Your doctor that treated you is going to have to be able to testify that the injuries that you currently have were caused by the accident you’re in or were substantially caused by the accident that you were in, such as aggravating your preexisting condition.

Search the Blog

Free Case Evaluation

Call or text now. Same-day answers from an attorney, not a call center.

Practice Areas

Recent Case Results

Jury Verdict ($923,000)
Personal Injury · Hillsborough County · 2026

A client slipped on a substance leaking from an Aquabag that a store failed to remove after Hurricane Irma. The client suffered a dislocated knee and other injuries.…

Charges Reduced to Probation
Criminal · Hillsborough County · 2026

A client was arrested on a second DUI with refusal and leaving the scene of an accident. The initial offer from the State was 60 days in jail.…